The Advantages of Investing in a Concrete Pool

July 1, 2025

Building a Pool in the Carolinas? Here’s Why Concrete Wins

If you’re thinking about adding a pool to your backyard, you’re not alone—especially here in the Carolinas, where a hot, humid summer day practically demands a cool backyard escape. And yes, as the Carolinas’ premier ready-mix concrete producer, we’re biased—we’ve seen how well concrete pools perform over the long haul.

A pool isn’t just about fun in the sun—it’s an investment in property value and long-term livability. That’s why the material and how your pool is constructed matter. If you focus only on the cheapest upfront option, you may end up paying more in the long run. You’ve probably heard the phrase, “buy once, cry once”—and it applies here. Initial cost is just one factor; how that pool holds up through seasons, storms, and years of use can make all the difference.

With deep regional experience, we’ve watched and helped Carolina homeowners reimagine their outdoor spaces to meet both climate demands and personal design goals. And in those conversations, concrete continues to rise to the top as a durable, high-performing solution.

Comparing Pool Types: Concrete vs. Fiberglass vs. Vinyl Liner

Let’s start with the basics. The three most common pool types are concrete, fiberglass, and vinyl liner. Each offers pros and cons depending on your goals.

Fiberglass Pools: Low Maintenance, Limited Options

Fiberglass pools are factory-molded and shipped in one piece, which makes them quick and easy to install. Their gelcoat surface feels smooth, resists algae growth, and requires less chemical adjustment and cleaning than concrete or vinyl.

But they come in pre-set shapes, sizes, and depths. If you’re dreaming of a custom layout or need something deeper than six feet, fiberglass may not meet your needs. At an average cost of $60,000 for a 12×24 model, you’re paying a premium for convenience—but sacrificing flexibility. According to HomeAdvisor, fiberglass pools typically range from $55,000 to $65,000.

Pros: Low maintenance, fast installation, modern appearance
Cons: Limited size and shape options, higher cost with fewer customization possibilities

Vinyl Liner Pools: Affordable But Less Durable

Vinyl liner pools generally have the lowest upfront cost, starting around $40,000. According to Forbes Home, they usually range from $35,000 to $65,000 depending on size and features.

They’re easy to install and flexible in layout. But they’re also the most fragile. Liners can tear from pets, debris, or general wear—and typically need replacing every 5–9 years. That adds up in long-term costs, and vinyl pools generally offer the least resale value.

Pros: Lower initial cost, customizable layout
Cons: Ongoing liner maintenance, lower long-term value

Why Concrete Pools Offer the Best Long-Term Value

Concrete pools offer full customization and long-term durability. They’ve long been the choice for homeowners who want something permanent, personal, and high-end. And it’s why we believe—especially here in the Carolinas—that concrete is often the best option for a pool that’s built to last.

Total Customization

Concrete can be poured into virtually any shape, size, or depth. Want a lap lane, tanning ledge, vanishing edge, or swim-up bar? Concrete gives you the freedom to design what fits your space and vision.

Built to Last

Unlike liners or prefabricated shells, concrete structures are truly long-lasting. With proper care, a concrete pool can last 50 years or more. Occasional resurfacing may be needed, but that’s a small trade-off for decades of reliable performance.

Designed for Safety

The textured surface of concrete provides better traction and slip resistance than smooth fiberglass—important if you have kids or elderly guests. While it can be a bit rough on bare feet, many homeowners appreciate the added grip.

Real Return on Investment

Concrete pools often add more resale value than other pool types. According to real-estate experts, a standard 14×28-foot inground concrete pool can increase a home’s value by 5–8%, especially in warm regions like the Carolinas.

Pros: Fully customizable, built to last, adds long-term value, safer surface
Cons: Higher upfront cost, longer installation time, occasional resurfacing required

Why Mix Quality Matters in a Concrete Pool

Most homeowners don’t spend much time thinking about the concrete mix behind their pool—and that’s perfectly normal. In most residential builds, contractors use a method called shotcrete or gunite, where concrete is sprayed into place using specialized equipment.

Still, the quality of that material is critical. At Concrete Supply Co., we specialize in ready-mix concrete. Our mixes are tailored to perform in Carolina conditions—resisting cracks, supporting smooth finishes, and holding up through years of sun, rain, and seasonal shifts.

You don’t need to understand the mix itself—but your builder should be working with a supplier who does. Choosing the right materials and the right partner ensures your pool performs beautifully for decades.

Partner With the Experts at Concrete Supply Co.

If you need high-quality concrete for your pool project, we’re here to help. Our team can supply the right ready-mix solution for your design and site conditions—and recommend local builders who know how to bring it to life.

Sources